Macquarie recently joined a growing number of universities worldwide in establishing a distinct promotion pathway via teaching excellence (Cashmore, Cane, & Cane, 2013).

It means that collecting, tagging, and organizing evidence of one’s teaching achievements is now more important than ever.

What can serve as evidence of my teaching achievements?

Evidence for teaching excellence can come from multiple sources and have different weight and validity (Subbaye & Vithal, 2017). The list below, while not ‘all-inclusive’, illustrates some potential sources you can use to evidence your teaching excellence. Ideally, your evidence will come from multiple sources to provide a breadth and depth of your teaching achievements.

Evidence sources   More details/Examples  
1. Teaching track record   A summary of your contributions to teaching-related activities, including, but not limited to:
unit co-ordination, curriculum design, lecturing, tutoring, student supervision, mentoring and supervising peers, teaching-related administrative activities, etc.   
2. Feedback from students  – Student survey feedback (e.g. LEUs & LETs)  
– Longitudinal student feedback (e.g., briefly assessing student attitude towards a subject at different times) 
– Other forms of student feedback, e.g., emails or award nominations from students 
– Alumni feedback  
Etc.  
Tips:  Tag or save feedback emails from students in a separate folder.  Back up if your work email is set to delete messages after 12 months.  
3. Feedback from peers – Formal or informal peer review of one’s learning design, curriculum and/or delivery  
– Testimonials from teaching teams  
– A peer review from an award winner or an accomplished L&T colleague on a particular aspect of your teaching 
Etc.  
Tip:  Peer review can be done by colleagues at MQ, other institutions as well as industry partners.  
4. Self-reflection and self-evaluation  Record-keeping of teaching practice with a focus on critical reflection (identifying issues), e.g., a reflective journal, reflective course memo at the end of the semester 
5. Improvements in teaching practice    Planning, implementing, and assessing/reflecting on improvements to your teaching practice.  
Tips: Self-initiated improvements can be prompted by self-reflection, student or peer feedback or L&T innovations piloted/implemented.  Improvement can be at the scope of an individual task/ a whole unit or may have had positive impact beyond one unit to the programme or beyond.  
6. Observable outcomes  – Learning outcome measures (e.g. pre- and post- learning measures; research student completions) 
– Student engagement measures Increase in student enrolment due to pedagogical improvements  
– Rates of attrition, failure, progression to honours/post-graduate studies  
– Student achievements (employment, further study, awards & prizes)  

MQ examples:  
Increased student engagement after an iLearn unit redesign (tip: you can use iLearn analytics for evidence)  

Increased average grade after redesigning an assessment task Increased support for a diverse population of students, e.g., including indigenous perspectives or providing referrals or additional support to students with identified needs, etc.  

Benchmarking against units in other universities Increased employability rates after liaising with industry partners 

Student self-reported knowledge/skill gain at the end of the course   
7. Practice informed by research  – A clearly articulated teaching philosophy grounded in the scholarship of learning and teaching  
– Grounding one’s curriculum and/or teaching decisions in L&T scholarship and best practice   
8. Teaching portfolio A collection of artifacts (e.g., lesson plans; reflections; unit summaries; student feedback, etc.) that showcases your teaching achievements  
9. Personal teaching blogPosts about your L&T experiences, challenges and solutions, interviews with other educators, links to external resources, etc.   
10. Professional development   – Engaging with the scholarship of learning and teaching  
– Doing L&T professional development workshops and courses 
– Joining L&T communities, attending conferences and presentations, etc.    
11. Aligning one’s practice to MQ context  – Incorporating MQ-supported approaches, like embedding sustainability, indigenous perspectives, employability, active learning approaches, etc.  
– Adopting MQ-supported learning technologies, like Active Learning Platform, Learning Analytics, etc.  
– Being aware of TEQSA requirements and applying them in one’s teaching practice   
12. Peer recognition  – Invitations to speak on L&T events (or participate in L&T projects) 
– Advance HE Fellowship 
– L&T Awards (MQ or elsewhere) (winning or nomination) 
– Peer-reviewed or invited L&T publications 
– Being invited to be an external examiner  
– Contributions to discipline textbooks   
13. Impact on peers  – Providing peer feedback 
– Sharing one’s L&T practice with colleagues, e.g., presentations in the department meetings, contributing to a TECHE blog or elsewhere  
– Resources developed for colleagues/used at MQ and beyond 
– Contributions to L&T committees 
– Input into L&T policies    
– Teaching across subject and disciplinary boundaries that contribute to interdisciplinary / professional education  
14. Projects to advance L&T at Mq or within a discipline   Supporting or leading L&T projects (e.g., curriculum mapping; learning innovations, etc) Grants focused on L&T)
15. Industry recognition  – Employer ratings 
– Feedback on student performance from industry   

Found it useful?

Save it as a PDF handout (168 KB), and share with others!

Cashmore, A., Cane, C., & Cane, R. (2013). Rebalancing promotion in the HE sector: Is teaching excellence being rewarded. York: Higher Education Academy.

Subbaye, R., & Vithal, R. (2017). Teaching criteria that matter in university academic promotions. Assessment & Evaluation in Higher Education, 42(1), 37-60.

Posted by Olga Kozar

I'm a 'long-term' Mq girl. I did my PhD here and taught on different courses, ranging from 1st year to PhD students. I now work in Learning and Teaching, which I love. I have 2 young kids and a dog, and I love meeting other Mq people, so give me a shout if you'd like to talk 'learning and teaching' or would like to brainstorm together.

Leave a reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *